Favorite Songs of 2025 - Songs 12-22

I'm trying folks, honest! Here are the oft-ignored middle kids (but no Middle Kids) of this year's List.

12.    The Black Dog and the Wandering Boy by James McMurtry.

"The black dog and the wanderin' boy

Come around every night.

The wanderin' boy never gets any older

The black dog doesn't bite.

He just sits on the floor at the corner of the bed

Watchin' for the things that haunt.

They oughta both go away when I take my meds ...

But they don't."

Now officially a frequent List denizen, this is McMurtry's third appearance. How can you not love someone who paints such a vivid story in under five minutes? "Hey, somebody lied to me!" 

13.    Forever by The Tisburys.

"When the day’s lost and the night’s won

And the lights are home and nobody’s on

Are your bags packed? Is your life hacked?

Can you pull the strings coming from your back?"

The Tisburys seem to be trying to find those little victories. Good for them. This sounds very much like a '90's alternative/pop song (thinking Gin Blossoms), which is right in my musical wheelhouse.

14.    It's Alright by Cecilia Castleman.

"I don't need your money

I don't need your time

So I bought a ticket

I bought a ticket to ride, and I don't know why

But it sure feels right."

My spouse used to make fun of my loathing of the genre that I referred to as "angry white woman with guitar." But, to be clear, it was an acoustic guitar. And Ms. Castleman does not appear to be going away mad. Just going away.

15.    I'll Be Okay by Michigander.

"I'm knocked down and I'm still out

So if you see me on the ground it's okay

But I'm not okay right now."

Glad to hear that Michigander (a.k.a. Jason Singer) is working through his issues. He moved to Nashville and released his first album this year, so I'm gonna say that he will be okay.

16.    Armies of the Lord by The Mountain Goats.

"Trying to pantomime surprise

After we buried you at sunrise

With nothing you'd predicted coming true

Just doing what we'd promised we would do."

Another artist that it surprises me has never made The List until now. The Mountain Goats' latest work, "Through This Fire Across From Peter Balkan," is a concept album about a shipwreck and its (dwindling) survivors. It is likely the song released the latest in 2025 to make this year's List. Bonus: Lin-Manuel Miranda sings backup vocals on this song and three others on the album.    

17.    Cadillac by Colin Miller.

"Nascar crash on the big screen

Shirtless in July heat

And I'm helpless

Helpless, helpless."

Miller is from the Asheville, NC artist colony which has spawned, amongst others, the group Wednesday and last year's List topper MJ Lenderman. Cadillac is about the death of Gary King, the owner of the land on which Miller, Lenderman, Wednesday's Karly Hartzman, and other artists (musical and otherwise) were welcome to live and work on their craft.

18.    Sally, When the Wine Runs Out by ROLE MODEL.

"Heard through the grapevine

She can be a diva

Cold like Minnesota

Hotter than a fever."

The aforementioned popular artist in this year's List (9.4 million views of the "official video" on YouTube), this is one of those "guilty pleasure" songs that appear here every once in a while. I cannot defend its artistic merit, nor do I feel compelled to. Oh, yeah, and that appearance by someone whom the internets tell me is Charli XCX at 2:30 of the video? It's a whole 'nother thing. 

19.    Chateau Blues by Spoon.

"Well, you got it all?

But your lonely chateau blues

You got it all

Got the lonely chateau blues."

Proof, once again, that you can have it all and not have anything at all.

20.    Straight Line Was A Lie by The Beths.

"I thought I was getting better but I'm back to where I started

And the straight line was a circle

Yeah, the straight line was a lie."

The fourth appearance for New Zealand's The Beths on The List. They put me in mind of The Go-Gos or The Bangles with better musicianship. And, of course, New Zealand accents. Also check out Metal from their latest album (also called "Straight Line Was A Lie").

21.    Season of Charade by Birdtalker.

"Now the money's gone

But the dream lives on

Guess I'll keep slaving at the game show

Spin the wheel

Aw, but nothing's real (nothing is real)

Answer the answer with a question."

I think Birdtalker is on to a lot of us. Would be included in The List for the Jeopardy reference alone ...

22.    Float by Jay Som (featuring Jim Adkins).

"Is this the way it's supposed to be?

Measuring your misery

Pouring out what's left of me

Without you."

Go with the flow seems to be the message of this effort by Jay Som a.k.a. Melina Mae Duterte. I had to google who Jim Adkins was. Turns out, someone I should know: the lead singer of Jimmy Eat World.

Favorite Songs of 2022: Songs 1-11

We've come to the top of the list a little later than most years past, but hopefully not too late for you to appreciate my favorite eleven songs of 2022. 

1. Returner by Gang of Youths.

"Now I live by a motto, just like Assou-Ekotto

And it's 'F___ you and pay me,' it's a line I respect.

A below-average shooter, I'm hardly Batistuta

But the vision, the motivation I get."

We complete our Australian-centric list, naturally, with another artist from Down Under. Gang of Youths have made the list several times before. This is my favorite song from their excellent album Angel in Real Time because of the above lines and their soccer references, as well as the Pacific Islands chorus. Because my friend Charlie, also a GOY fan, says this is his least favorite of all on the record, I'm going to break the rules and give you a second song, a number 1.b., if you will, which is likely the most-played song from Angel in Real Time - In the Wake of Your Leave.

2. Rubberneckers by Christian Lee Hutson.

"I'm a self-esteem vending machine

A doctor's office magazine.

A funhouse at the county fair

A staircase to nowhere.

If you tell a lie for long enough,

Then it becomes the truth.

I am going to be okay some day,

With or without you.

With or without you."

The next three songs are all in the running for my favorite lyrics of the year. I believe that it's hard to find a word in this song that is out of place. If you listen closely to the chorus, you'll likely hear the voice of an artist mentioned in the first edition of this year's list with the promise that she'd reappear. She also produced Hutson's album Quitters, along with her frequent collaborator Conor Oberst.

3. Blush by Matt Nathanson. 

"And when the sun is getting lower

And your wildest days are done.

And they ask you about a photograph

From back when you were young.

Baby, you don't have to tell 'em

What you did when we were us.

But when you think about it

I hope you blush,

Just a little bit.

When you think about it

I hope you blush."

Another song about lost love, but one fondly remembered. The "We looked good, we looked good, we looked good" chorus makes me smile everytime I hear it. And I also really like the words, and the feel, of this song overall as well.

4. Canola Fields by James McMurtry.

James McMurtry at Mountain Stage.

"And there's not much moving on the romance radar

Not that I'm craving it all that much.

But I still need to feel, every once in a while

The warmth of a smile and a touch.

In a way back corner of a cross-town bus,

We were hiding out under my hat.

Cashing in on a thirty-year crush.

You can't be young and do that,

You can't be young and do that."

The (now long ago) aforesaid old favorite I got to see in 2022, at Mountain Stage. As already mentioned, I have a hard time deciding whether these lines are my favorite ones of 2022, or whether one of the two songs immediately above contain them.

5. American Teenager by Ethel Cain.

"I do it for my daddy

And I do it for Dale

I'm doing what I want and, damn

I'm doing it well.

For me, for me,

For me, for me."

Quite the backstory for Hayden Silas Anhedonia a.k.a. Ethel Cain (according to Wikipedia, anyway). Her voice reminds me of an American Dolores O'Riordan (of The Cranberries). A lovely, haunting song.

6. Country by Good Morning.

"Yeah, I think it's a little bit different now

I got a boyfriend and I got a psych.

I know that one really cares about me,

And, at least, that the other one tries."

Yet another Australian band, although honestly they sound very American to me (again - guess I just need to give up trying to figure that out). A really catchy song with great lyrics about a lost friendship - but I love the instrumental intro and outro best of all.

7. Time Escaping by Big Thief.

"Desert ground so cold and clean

Spreading out like a magazine

Reading the dirt like gossip.

What do the weeds say? They say:

'Everything, everything, everything falls through

Each dimension breaks in two

Like the two hands clapping ...

Like the two wings flapping.'"

So many really good songs on Big Thief's double album Dragon New Warm Mountain I Believe in You. This is my favorite, but if you're inclined, check out "Certainty," "No Reason," and "Little Things" too.

8. Love Is Yours by Flasher. 

"It's like a knock on the door,

I've never heard it before,

You have me opening, oh so naturally.

It's better than the real thing,

I'm seeing 2020,

You got me missing what I didn't know I need."

One of several songs (numbers 2, 5, 6, and 11 are the others, to be precise) from artists in the Top 11 that I didn't know before 2022, but am glad I do now. Flasher sounds like a cross between The Dandy Warhols and The New Pornographers to me.

9. Here to Forever by Death Cab for Cutie.

"Oh, these days it's so hard to relax

You gotta hold a gun to my back

To make me smile

To make me smile."

Sounds like our old friend Ben Gibbard spent the pandemic contemplating his mortality. Completely understandable.

10. Free by Florence + The Machine. 

"I'm always running from something

I push it back, but it keeps on coming.

And being clever never got me very far,

Because it's all in my head.

And 'You're too sensitive,' they said.

I said, 'Okay, but let's discuss this at the hospital.'"

Florence has appeared on the list several times before - she's back and strong as ever. I don't think I've ever said this before, but that harpist can jam! "And for a moment, when I'm dancing ... I am free." If only we all could be.

11. Rewind by Daybed.

"And I hoped maybe time would slow

Feels like the end of a road

With all the friends I used to know."

And here I thought Hometown was an obscure choice. This song now has 144 YouTube views (and at least four are mine). I love the music on this one (particularly the banjo). Apparently Daybed = Reagan Smith, the banjo player of The Oh Hellos (which, I guess, explains why the banjo is so good).

Favorite Songs of 2015 - Songs 23-33

Gather round boys and girls. It's that time of year, when we hear tales of a divine birth, jolly elves, and flying reindeer. And get to listen to what I think is some pretty good music. So much good music that, unlike past lists that were limited to 30 songs, this year's offering includes three bonus tracks!

As in prior years, the list is limited to songs released in 2014 or 2015. And that's about it as far as rules go. You'll hear a variety of songs that could be variously described as alternative, indie, pop, Americana, soul, and maybe even country.

Oh, one disclaimer: while a few of these songs may appear on one critic or the other's "best of" lists, I  do not profess to be a critic. Just an appreciator. And I hope you will appreciate at least a few of these offerings.

23. Fool for Love by Lord Huron.

"I stare into the endless sky
And the sordid tale of my life goes by.
I drift into the great unknown
And I really don't know where I'm going."

Missed Lord Huron at Bonnaroo in 2013 (despite E's best effort to the contrary), but caught them live this summer in Columbia, SC. They've made prior lists before, and will again later on this year's.

Lord Huron at the Music Farm in Columbia, SC. (photo by me)

24. Shut Up and Dance by Walk the Moon.

"We were victims of the night.
The chemical, physical, kryptonite.
Helpless to the bass and the fading light.
Oh we were bound to get together,
Bound to get together."

Admittedly a lightweight song lyrically. But so darn catchy. The pop song of the summer of 2015 for me.

25. Cavalry by Kingsley Flood.

"I've been thinking I've been drinking, I've been scraping rust.
I've been keeping clean, the frames that have collected dust.
Monday nights I watch the fights, on Thursdays I play cards.
But maybe just this week, I'll skip out on both."

Thought this was a standard breakup song until I studied the lyrics some more. It's clearly about the protagonist and his family - though I'm not sure if he's leaving home, or just asking them to get their house in order before he does.

26. Perth by Beirut.

"Blood on the sand
Paint on the water.
I skipped around
Asking for you."

Beirut, too, has appeared on past lists and will reappear on this one as well. Their album No No No is one of my favorites of the past year.

27. Waiting for My Time to Come by Colony House.

"I'm just waiting on the seasons to change.
Waiting for the curtain to fall.
I could lose my cool
Like a restless fool.
But I'm waiting for my time to come."

Horns and a big chorus of fresh-faced youngsters - what's not to like? I dare you to watch the video and not be at least a wee bit happier than you were four minutes earlier.

28.  Rollercoaster by Bleachers.

"Now I'm running and I won't stop I don't wanna go.
I think about it everyday and night, I can't let go.
And, hey, I'm never the same.
It's a hundred miles an hour on a dirt road running away."

A repeat of sorts as Bleachers' I Wanna Get Better was Number 5 on last year's list. Can't help but hear a little Billy Idol in this one.

 29. How'm I Gonna Find You Now by James McMurtry.

"I remember when I met you I's in love in one fell swoop.
You had a blade in your pocket and a rag in your belt loop.
Guys a hoverin' 'round the bar like gulls on the ocean
At the end of your shift just in case you got the notion.
Watch you washin' all the glassware, poetry in motion.
I'd a roped the moon for you.
How'm I gonna find you now?"

A Dylanesque largely spoken word song from a Dylanesque songwriter.

30. What Kind of Man by Florence + The Machine.

"What kind of man loves like this?

To let me dangle
at a cruel angle.
Oh my feet don't touch the floor.
Sometimes you're half in
and then you're half out.
But you never close the door."

I think there are more bands fronted by female singers on this year's list than ever before. And if that's the case, Florence has to be among them, doesn't she?

31. Bullets by Wild Child.

"Oh, I'm so glad, you found a cure.
It was so sad when you weren't sure.
I know you think, we need to talk.
You said, those regrets will burn a hole
In my black and withered soul.
You're gonna think I'm wicked when I walk."

See what I told you about female singers? I've always liked incongruous songs and this is one - a bouncy beat masking some pretty depressing lyrics.

32. Make Me Do It Again by Jim Noir.

"Come through the door,
Tell me more.
Make it up,
Make me feel,
Make me do it again."

Sounds like a Beatles' song to me. Sorry, can't find a link to a video for it.

33. You Must Have Met Little Caroline? by JD McPherson.

"Do you feel like I feel
Half a dozen times a day
When the lights go out
And your thoughts drift away?"

I've seen JD twice in person -- once at Bonnaroo in 2013, then again this year at Mountain Stage. Great rockabilly sound that's even better live. And, yes, I feel I know him well enough now to call him by his first name.